Are you connected for success? Most research respondents ranked themselves higher than they landed on the Distributed Enterprise Transformation Index, developed by IDC and Comcast Business. To see how you stack-up, read the white paper and complete the Distributed Enterprise Peer Assessment to receive a custom report with recommendations to get to the next level for today’s digital age.
57% of companies consider themselves IT "innovators," but only 14% are Ultra-Connected.
Today’s fast-paced business environment requires organizations to be highly agile and responsive, and as customer interactions are pushed to frontline employees, workers in remote locations and branch offices require greater levels of connectivity across the organization. Businesses with multiple locations need a reliable distributed enterprise network that provides employees access to critical business applications from any device, in any location with high levels of availability, security, and reliability.
To understand today’s distributed enterprise landscape, IDC conducted a survey of IT professionals in U.S. businesses with five or more locations. While respondents gave great importance to distributed enterprise networking, we were surprised at how many companies are not getting it right. For example, most companies claimed to have redundancy in their distributed enterprise networks. This “redundancy” is often based on having multiple virtual networks from the same provider (i.e., coming into the location over the same physical connection), whereas true redundancy requires separate network connections.
Companies Are at Different Levels of Advancement
IDC used this survey to develop a Distributed Enterprise Transformation Index describing the level of advancement of any given company and, based on this index, identified four levels of distributed enterprise networking sophistication. These levels, from highest to lowest, are as follows:
Ultra-Connecteds: The most advanced level of distributed enterprise connectivity is Ultra-Connecteds. Their priority is delivering critical business applications to the maximum number of offices and remote users. Because they also tend to be complex organizations, Ultra-Connecteds rely on third-party providers to supplement or take the place of in-house resources to manage their distributed enterprise networks. They use a mix of public internet and private WAN in their distributed enterprise network. They are more likely to deploy hybrid cloud solutions in their network as well as connect to cloud solutions via a dedicated private network. They also have the highest percentage (69%) of business applications available to employees working from home/remote offices. Ultra-Connecteds are most concentrated in industries such as securities, healthcare, and retail.
Branch-Centrics: The next level of distributed enterprise connectivity is Branch-Centrics. They extend their use of web-based management tools to all locations, are great users of public cloud SaaS in their IT infrastructure, and provide remote office cloud connectivity through their datacenter via a private network. They enable 54% of applications to be accessible by employees working from home/remote offices. Representative industries include banking, IT, and energy/utilities.
HQ-Centrics: HQ-Centrics can be described as about halfway there in terms of their distributed enterprise connectivity advancement. Just 49% of their business applications are available to employees working from home/remote offices, and while they use web-based network management tools, these tools are managed by in-house staff and are available for larger locations only. They use direct ISP-based internet access to connect branch offices to the cloud. HQ-Centrics are often found in insurance and construction industries.
Resisters: Resisters have the lowest level of distributed enterprise network connectivity. They have the fewest number (39%) of business applications available to employees working from home/remote offices and tend to use their own in-house resources to manage distributed enterprise connectivity. They use traditional infrastructures and public cloud, and remote offices have little say in enterprise connectivity strategy. They are typically found in manufacturing, professional services, hospitality, and agriculture/mining.
Distributed Enterprise Is a Core Component of Digital Transformation
Digital transformation is one of the hottest topics in business today. And for good reason. A wealth of experience confirms the benefits of going digital. Ultra-Connecteds are closer to realizing the promise of digital transformation because they are making enterprise applications better and more available to frontline employees and customers, improving the customer experience and driving greater flexibility for the enterprise.
Being Distributed Is Good for Business
IDC found that companies with the most advanced levels of distributed enterprise network connectivity have the best business outcomes. Ultra-Connecteds outperform across all business key performance indicators (KPIs) studied, such as revenue growth, customer satisfaction, employee productivity, and time to market. For example, in our study, Ultra- Connecteds grew revenue at 21% over a three-year period, whereas Resisters grew at 11%. In other words, having a high Distributed Enterprise Transformation Index score is good for business.
Companies Should Take Steps Now
We identified some of the key attributes and practices separating levels of distributed enterprise networking sophistication. The more advanced companies are characterized by:
- Placing greater focus on distributed enterprise connectivity fundamentals
- Recognizing that cloud is playing a central role in digital transformation for the business
- Leveraging extensive use of third-party providers to deliver connectivity services
Companies looking to improve their business outcomes should assess their distributed enterprise strategy and understand where they fit on the Distributed Enterprise Transformation Index. Companies should consider new technologies and solutions to help them better improve connectivity, security, and redundancy and, critically, they should consider the use of third-party experts to help guide them through this journey, freeing up internal IT resources for other mission-critical tasks.
About This Study
This IDC study is based on a survey of 501 IT professionals (C-level executives, vice presidents, and directors). The respondents came from organizations with five or more separate U.S. locations, representing a mix of industries, with emphasis on hospitality, healthcare providers, retail, and banking. For a more detailed description of the study methodology, see the Appendix.
Distributed Enterprise Networking Is Critical to Today’s Business
Distributed Enterprise Networking Helps Employees Better Serve Customers
Today’s dynamic business environment requires companies to be highly agile while providing the best possible customer experience. Ninety three percent of survey respondents said that time to market for new products/services is a top criterion for measuring overall business success. As responsibility for customer interactions and other critical business processes is pushed out to frontline employees, remote employees require greater degrees of enterprise application access. However, access to critical business tools and information can be problematic if delivered over an unstable network. An unreliable, insecure network with poor quality of service can have a negative impact on the customer experience and the organization’s competitiveness.
Companies Connect in Many Ways
The survey revealed that companies are providing distributed enterprise connectivity in a variety of ways, with no single approach dominating (see Figure 1). Companies use a blend of technologies such as public internet, private WAN, and a mix of private and public networks.
Ethernet services and Layer 3 IP are the most common network technologies used for distributed enterprise connectivity. Ethernet private line (EPL) and Ethernet virtual private line (EVPL) services were deployed by 51% of respondents; Layer 3 IP, including managed Layer 3 MPLS/VPN IPsec, was deployed by 45% of respondents; and E-LAN Ethernet services was deployed by 45% of respondents.
Enterprise Connectivity Needs to Be Secure and Reliable and Offer Sufficient Bandwidth
With regards to providing distributed enterprise connectivity, organizations must get the basics right. Respondents indicated that the most important aspects of their distributed enterprise connectivity strategy are security, reliability, and bandwidth sufficiency (see Figure 2). They ranked these factors above other factors such as tailoring the network to specific connectivity needs.
But Many Companies Aren’t Doing Distributed Enterprise Connectivity Right
Nearly Half of Business Applications Are Not Available to All Remote Employees
Despite the importance of business agility and providing access to business applications to frontline employees, a surprisingly low number of businesses make all enterprise applications available to remote employees (i.e., employees working from remote offices or home offices or traveling on the road). In our survey, on average, only 53% of organizations’ business applications are available to all remote employees, and one-third of companies make less than half of business applications available to remote employees.
Most Companies Use Public Internet for Mission-Critical Applications
Another measure of the poor state of distributed enterprise connectivity is the degree to which companies entrust remote application access to the public internet. Seventy-five percent of companies in our survey provide executives working from home with access to mission-critical applications over the public internet, and only 6% provide a separate connection for business traffic (see Figure 3). Relying on the public internet rather than a secured network opens companies to vulnerabilities such as security threats and connectivity issues and possibly insufficient bandwidth or disrupted service.
Companies Have Insufficient Remote Office Redundancy
Companies are putting their distributed enterprise connectivity at risk by not having a true redundancy strategy in place. In the survey, 57% of companies said that they are running “redundant private networks via a single provider,” with 23% using multiple service providers and 17% using the public internet as a backup to their private network. IDC notes that using a single provider, even with redundant private networks, does not provide full redundancy because carrying all traffic into remote locations over one physical connection represents a single point of failure. True redundancy requires separate connections coming into the building.
Measuring Distributed Networking Advancement: The IDC Distributed Enterprise Transformation Index
To understand how companies are approaching distributed enterprise networking and draw lessons from the leaders, IDC categorized survey respondents by the level of advancement of their distributed enterprise networking strategy. IDC calls this the Distributed Enterprise Transformation Index. Companies were measured and ranked by distributed enterprise networking behaviors that were most closely linked to positive business outcomes. A description of the four levels is summarized below.
Companies Are Not as Advanced as They Think
Companies believe that they are more advanced than they actually are. IDC compared how respondents characterize their companies’ adoption of IT service delivery models with where they scored on the Distributed Enterprise Transformation Index. The results show a significant gap between perception and reality. In the survey, 57% of companies characterize themselves as IT “innovator” but, in contrast, only 14% are classified as Ultra-Connecteds, the top category in the Distributed Enterprise Transformation Index. This discrepancy between perception (self-assessed IT sophistication) and reality (Distributed Enterprise Transformation Index) implies that the companies have a blind spot with regard to their level of distributed enterprise networking sophistication, which could leave them vulnerable to performance, reliability, or security concerns in the network.
Advanced Companies Have the Best Business Outcomes
Companies at the top of the Distributed Enterprise Transformation Index have the best business performance outcomes. This was true across all business KPIs in the study, including revenue, profit margin, customer satisfaction/retention, employee productivity, and time to market for new products and services.
Best Practices in Distributed Enterprise Networking
Achieving the greatest levels of distributed enterprise networking advancement requires organizations to focus on three critical areas identified by IDC, which characterize distributed enterprise networking sophistication:
- Distributed enterprise connectivity fundamentals
- Adoption of cloud solutions and connectivity
- Third-party managed services
Need to Provide Connectivity Fundamentals
Distributed enterprise connectivity is built upon three fundamentals: security, cloud services availability, and sufficient bandwidth to support the needs of remote locations. These were the three most important aspects of distributed connectivity among survey respondents across the board, with Ultra-Connecteds placing the greatest emphasis on these three connectivity fundamentals.
Ultra-Connecteds place greater importance on reliability of distributed enterprise connectivity — 86% of Ultra-Connecteds said this is important compared with 76% of Resisters. They are much more likely to provide separate business connections for executives working from home — 22% of Ultra-Connecteds provide separate connections compared with 4% of Resisters. They are also more likely to make business applications available to executives working from home — 70% of Ultra-Connecteds provide access compared with 40% of Resisters.
Ultra-Connecteds are more likely to factor in connectivity needs of their remote offices as part of managing their distributed enterprise strategy. In other words, the more advanced companies are listening to the needs of their remote offices and responding to them.
Importance of Cloud
Cloud is critical to distributed enterprise connectivity strategy, with survey respondents reporting 76% of business applications carried over the cloud today. Further, the more advanced companies are both using more cloud (83% of Ultra-Connecteds versus 71% of Resisters) and placing a higher importance on cloud (53% of Ultra-Connecteds said providing connectivity to SaaS solutions such as salesforce.com and Microsoft Office 365 is important to their distributed enterprise connectivity strategy compared with 35% of Resisters).
Increasing use of cloud has an impact on distributed enterprise connectivity. Organizations must now consider bandwidth and security requirements associated with hybrid cloud and splitting applications. Many companies are using cloud applications, but they are doing so over the public internet and managing them in-house over a traditional IT infrastructure. With greater use of cloud services (78% of survey respondents are using Microsoft Office 365), organizations must also consider the impact on bandwidth needs and the ability to migrate congestion during peak times.
Ultra-Connecteds understand this better than anyone does because they are using cloud to the greatest degree. For example, they are more likely to have hybrid cloud in their distributed enterprise network.
To address these needs, Ultra-Connecteds are taking a demonstrably different approach to their distributed enterprise connectivity. Forty-two percent of Ultra-Connecteds are providing dedicated private networks for cloud services compared with less than 12% for the rest of the sample. IDC notes that this is still fewer than half of Ultra-Connecteds, which means there is still room for improvement, and IDC expects this figure to grow in the future.
Use of Third-Party Managed Services
A defining characteristic of more advanced distributed enterprise networking companies is their use of third-party managed services. These companies appreciate that the use of third parties frees up their internal IT staff to focus on tasks more central to the business’ focus. Outsourcing networking services to third parties enables these companies to take advantage of the expertise the third parties bring to the table without having to hire in-house world-class networking and security staff.
Ultra-Connecteds are much more likely to use third parties for managing some or all of their distributed enterprise connectivity. Eighty-one percent of Ultra-Connecteds outsource distributed enterprise connectivity to third parties compared with 25% of Resisters, which are still relying heavily upon in-house staff to manage distributed enterprise connectivity.
Some organizations practice a centralized approach and some practice a decentralized approach to managing distributed enterprise connectivity, but the core difference is that the most advanced companies are using third parties to perform their centralized management, while the least advanced are managing using in-house resources. Ultra-Connecteds make greater use of third-party providers (42%) for central distributed enterprise network management, whereas Resisters are more likely to use in-house resources for centralized network management (41%).
More advanced companies are also more likely to select their managed services partners in a sophisticated way, using multiple metrics to assess their providers. When implementing third-party managed services, Ultra-Connecteds are more likely to consider multiple factors such as device types, applications, and cloud connectivity needs. In comparison, Resisters tend to base their partnering decisions on location only.
Better Business Outcomes
This study shows that the higher a company is on the Distributed Enterprise Transformation Index, the better its business outcomes. This was true across each of the outcomes studied, meaning that more distributed enterprises had more robust revenue growth, lower costs, better customer satisfaction, and better employee productivity.
Distributed enterprises have the competitive advantage of being closer to their customers than more centralized organizations and should derive better business outcomes as a result. By optimizing their distributed enterprise networking strategy, Ultra-Connecteds are seeing better business outcomes and enjoying two to three times the business benefits compared with Resisters.
But Even the Most Advanced Companies Have Room to Grow
Even though Ultra-Connecteds display the most advanced level of distributed enterprise connectivity, they still have room for improvement. While they rely more on their distributed enterprise networks and provide greater levels of service to their users, they can do more to maximize their connectivity fundamentals and utilize outside expertise.
Distributed enterprise networking is key to a business’ success, not least of which is because of its role in delivering enterprise applications to frontline workers. Yet, this study found only 14% of companies to be Ultra-Connecteds, the category with the most advanced distributed enterprise connectivity. Companies at all levels can improve their distributed enterprise connectivity and, by implication, realize greater business performance outcomes. Key steps include the following:
Assess your distributed enterprise strategy. Take stock of how well your network performs with all applications, devices, and remote offices/locations. Ensure all executives working from home can access the business applications and cloud services to perform their critical business functions. While you can do this assessment using in-house staff, it is likely even better to find an expert third-party service provider to do it for you.
Understand where your organization stands on the Distributed Enterprise Transformation Index scale. IDC has developed a tool to assess where you fit on the Distributed Enterprise Transformation Index as well as what you can do to improve your position on the scale and business benefits you could expect for doing so. The tool can be found at www.distributedenterpriseindex.com.
Upgrade your networking technology accordingly. Assess distributed enterprise solutions and consider new technologies that can be utilized to bolster connectivity, improve security, and establish true redundancy.
Get help from the experts. The most advanced companies turn to third-party providers for their expertise. With the growing complexity of applications, devices, and remote locations, it is becoming more difficult to maintain the required networking and security staff to manage a distributed enterprise network in-house. By leveraging expertise from third parties, your staff can focus on what you do best and outsource the rest.
Distributed enterprise networking plays a crucial role to the business. It is the connective tissue fastening together companies’ remote locations, applications, and devices. Companies require seamless, responsive accessibility to business applications to ensure business agility and allow for digital transformation initiatives. This study identifies four categories of distributed enterprise networking sophistication: Ultra-Connecteds, Branch-Centrics, HQ-Centrics, and Resisters, with the greater level of enterprise networking sophistication corresponding to greater levels of business success, such as reduced time to market and operational costs, increased employee productivity, customer satisfaction, revenue, and profit.
For Ultra-Connecteds, the companies with the greatest levels of distributed enterprise networking, the business outcomes are the greatest. Ultra-Connecteds are placing greater attention on getting their connectivity right with better network security, bandwidth, and connectivity. They are adopting more cloud-based solutions to enable wider and secure access to business tools and information. They are freeing up their IT staff to focus on tasks more central to business success and growth by using more third-party managed services. In addition, Ultra-Connecteds listen more to the connectivity needs of their remote/branch offices.
Unfortunately, many companies are not acting on these practices in the most productive way. To highlight a few shortfalls, only slightly more than half of business applications are available to remote office employees; most companies in the survey that allow access to mission-critical applications are doing so over public internet, and many of the companies have insufficient network redundancy in place, which leaves them vulnerable to a host of issues that can negatively impact business performance.
Companies at all levels should draw lessons from the leaders, assess their distributed networking strategy to see where they fit on the Distributed Enterprise Transformation Index scale, and implement appropriate new technologies. Importantly, they should take a page from the Ultra-Connecteds and look to third-party expertise for help in their journey.
The information for this white paper came from IDC’s April 2016 Enterprise Network and Managed Solutions Survey, sponsored by Comcast Business. IDC surveyed 501 U.S. IT professionals (C-level executives, vice presidents, and directors) with responsibilities for their organizations’ planning, implementation, and purchasing of distributed enterprise/remote office networking and connectivity services. They came from organizations with five or more United States–based locations across a set of key industries including hospitality (n = 100), healthcare providers (n = 100), retail (n = 100), banking (n = 100), and other industries (n = 100) (excluding government/education). Survey respondents were asked about their current approach to providing distributed enterprise/remote office connectivity, technologies used, criteria for implementing third-party managed services, cloud connectivity, and services and applications deployed. In addition, they were asked about a variety of KPI metrics, which enabled IDC to create an index linking IT infrastructure and accessibility to business applications/tools to KPIs.
On the basis of the survey results, IDC classified companies into four different sophistication categories — Resisters, HQ-Centrics, Branch-Centrics, and Ultra-Connecteds — using the following methodology:
- Responses to all questions in the survey were scored on a 4-point maturity scale. For example, for the question, “Which statement best characterizes your organization’s approach to providing distributed enterprise/remote office connectivity?” public internet = 1 point and private WAN = 3 points.
- IDC performed statistical analysis to identify questions best correlated to positive business outcomes. For example, the question, “What is the importance of ERP cloud applications in the distributed enterprise?” had a high correlation to the 6 measured business outcomes.
- IDC selected a subset of 13 questions with the highest statistical correlation that also balanced the range of distributed enterprise strategy and cloud topics addressed in the survey.
- Using the 13 questions, IDC created a maturity scoring histogram for all respondents and identified cut-off ranges for the four Distributed Enterprise Transformation Index sophistication categories based on mean and standard deviations.
Download this white paper as a PDF here.